A Gift for the Medici
December 1513 · Machiavelli, in exile outside Florence, with a finished book on how power is held
Ten months ago his name was on a list. He was arrested, hung by the wrists with his arms behind his back and dropped six times, and let go still denying everything, because there was nothing to admit. The family that ordered it now runs Florence.
He has spent the autumn on a small farm arguing with woodcutters and losing coppers at cards, and in the evenings changing into the clothes he used to wear in government and reading the ancient historians. Out of that he has written a short book about how power is actually taken and held.
The manuscript could go to the Medici with a dedication. He has drafted one. It says he has nothing more valuable to offer than his knowledge of the actions of great men, and that he hopes it will be read.
He is asking the people who tortured him for a job, in writing, and telling them the truest things he knows in order to get it.
Or the manuscript stays in a drawer, and he keeps his silence, and goes on losing at cards.
On your own? Play it first, then reveal.
Reveal what happened
What really happened
He sent it, dedicated to Lorenzo de' Medici, and got nothing; there is a story, unverifiable, that Lorenzo was given a pair of hunting dogs the same day and paid more attention to those. The Prince was not printed until 1532, five years after Machiavelli died. He also wrote the Discourses on Livy in these years, a much longer argument that a free republic is the best of all governments, and it is the shorter book the world read. When the republic was restored in 1527 the republicans passed him over for having courted the Medici, and he died weeks later, aged fifty-eight, having been distrusted by both sides for being the other one.
The philosophers weigh in
"He had watched power at close range for fourteen years and written down what it actually does. Keeping that in a drawer out of injured feeling would have been the one genuinely useless thing he could do with it."
"The rope was theirs and the farm is theirs and the appointment would have been theirs. The only thing in the whole account that was ever his was whether he asked, and he gave that away too."