MORALIA
MORALIAAbout
House of the Scales19 Nov 2026

Nonsense Upon Stilts

1790s · Bentham, an honorary citizen of the French Republic, reading the Declaration of the Rights of Man

The French have made him an honorary citizen of the Republic. It is a real honor and it is meant sincerely; they have read him, and they think he is one of theirs.

He has read their Declaration.

And it is, on his analysis, incoherent. It asserts that men have rights which are natural, imprescriptible and prior to any government; and he can show, line by line, that nothing of the kind exists. A right is something a law creates and enforces. Before there is law there are no rights, there are only wants with a strong feeling attached. Writing wants down in capital letters and calling them eternal does not create the enforcement, it only makes the sentence unfalsifiable.

The document is also, at this moment, the most effective instrument for ending arbitrary imprisonment and hereditary privilege that anyone has produced in a thousand years.

He can take it apart. Nobody else in Europe can do it as thoroughly, which is exactly the problem.

Let it stand
"It is freeing people this year. A demolition written by the most respected analyst alive will be quoted for two centuries by every government that wants a reason, and none of them will care that your point was technical."
or
Take it apart
"Rights that rest on an assertion rest on nothing, and the first government that tests it will discover that. Build them on what actually holds them up (law, and what the law is for) or watch them evaporate the first time they are inconvenient."
Play it in Moralia

On your own? Play it first, then reveal.

Reveal what happened

What really happened

He wrote it: Anarchical Fallacies, going through the Declaration article by article, where natural and imprescriptible rights are called nonsense upon stilts. He never published it in English; it appeared in French, through his editor, in 1816, and in English only after his death. The phrase has been used against rights language ever since, including by people who would have appalled him. Everything he actually wanted from law he argued for on his own grounds and most of it arrived: prison reform, free education, the secret ballot, votes for women, animal welfare, decriminalization. He also spent twenty years on a prison whose principle is that the inmate can never know when he is watched, and put a defense of decriminalizing homosexuality in a drawer for a hundred and fifty years.

The philosophers weigh in

Francis·Let it stand

"There were people coming out of the Bastille while he was checking the wording. I do not say he is wrong about the wording. I say I have never once seen the checking of it get anybody out of anywhere."

Ibn Rushd·Write it

"A conclusion that is true and a demonstration that is invalid do not make each other respectable. The friends of a good law serve it worst by refusing to hear where it is weakest; its enemies will find that place regardless."

More about Jeremy Bentham →

All past stories →