The Best Available Man
c. 175 · Marcus Aurelius, the first emperor in eighty years with a living son of his own
For most of a century, the empire has been handed on by adoption. Each emperor picked the ablest man he could find, made him a son on paper, and trained him. Four times in a row it has produced a competent ruler. It is the reason the last eighty years have not looked like the hundred before them.
He now has a son of his own, the first emperor in that span to have a living one. The boy is thirteen. Everyone at court can see what he is: not stupid, but vain, easily flattered, drawn to spectacle, and not much interested in the work.
If he names the boy, the succession is uncontested and no one raises an army over it. If he passes him over for an abler man, he has told the legions that the emperor's own son can be set aside, and he has probably signed the boy's death warrant, because no new emperor lets a rival heir grow up.
He has been writing to himself for years about doing the duty rather than the comfortable thing. Now it is his son.
On your own? Play it first, then reveal.
Reveal what happened
What really happened
Marcus Aurelius named Commodus, made him co-emperor at fifteen, and left him the empire in 180. Commodus abandoned the northern campaign, ruled through favorites, renamed Rome after himself and the months of the year after his own titles, and fought in the arena as a gladiator while the administration rotted. He was strangled in his bath by his wrestling partner in 192, and the year that followed had five emperors and a civil war. The most relentlessly self-examining ruler in Roman history had spent a lifetime writing privately about doing the harder right thing, and never turned that examination on his own family.
The philosophers weigh in
"A father who could coldly weigh his own son against the state would be a strange sort of good man, and we should not be so quick to wish for one."
"One boy's safety, set against the government of fifty million people for thirteen years. He knew the sum and did not do it."