The Only Man Who Called
c. 501 BC · Confucius, unemployed in his fifties, invited to serve a man who seized a town by force
He is in his fifties and nobody has hired him. He has been to courts that humored him, courts that ignored him, and one that put him off for a year and then stopped answering. What he offers rulers is the argument that a state is held up by character rather than by law and punishment, and no ruler has yet found this useful.
Now an invitation has arrived, and it is serious. A man has seized a walled town from the family that holds real power in Lu, and he is offering to put the whole administration in the hands of a teacher who will tell him how to run it.
He is a usurper. He took the town by force from men who had themselves usurped it from the duke, which is either an argument in his favor or the reason there is nothing left to argue about.
He wants to go. He says so out loud: that surely, given a state, he could make a new Zhou in the east.
His oldest student is standing in front of him, visibly appalled, and asking why a man who has spent forty years on legitimacy would go to this one.
On your own? Play it first, then reveal.
Reveal what happened
What really happened
He did not go. The Analects preserves the exchange (Zilu's objection, and Confucius's own wistful reply that surely he could make a Zhou in the east) and then simply records that in the end he did not go, without explaining why. He spent roughly fourteen more years traveling between courts that did not want him, was once nearly killed by a mob who mistook him for someone else, came home in his late sixties and taught. He wrote no book; the Analects is his students' record, assembled after his death. By his own measure he failed completely. Within four centuries his teaching was the official doctrine of imperial China, and it stayed that way for two thousand years.
The philosophers weigh in
"A warped board is straightened by a straight edge. He was the straight edge, and there is no version of leaning on a usurper's wall that leaves it straight."
"He wanted to go. He says so in his own students' record. He then spent fourteen years walking between courts and died having governed nothing, and the world had to wait three hundred years for someone less scrupulous to install him."