MORALIA
MORALIAAbout
House of the Flame2 Nov 2026

The Question He Never Asked

1248 · Rumi, after Shams of Tabriz has vanished from Konya a second time

The friend is gone again and this time nobody can find him.

The household is not grieving. It has been two years of a man of forty abandoning his lectures, his students and his family for a wandering dervish nobody can place, and the relief in the rooms is badly hidden.

There is a version going around the city. That there was a knock at the door one night, that Shams went out to it, that there was a cry, and that some of the household were waiting in the courtyard. His own son is named in it.

He can ask. He can put the question to the boy directly, in a room, tonight, and get an answer or a silence that is an answer, and then live in a house where that has been said out loud.

Or he can go on looking. He can travel to Damascus twice, and ask strangers, and come home, and never once put it to the person under his own roof.

He is going to write forty thousand lines out of this. He does not know that yet.

Put the question to his son
"You are choosing not to know because knowing would cost you what is left of your family. That is not grief and it is not love. It is a decision, and the man in the courtyard is owed the other one."
or
Never ask
"An answer brings nobody back and takes the last people you have. Some questions are not asked because the asking is the only part of it you would actually get."
Play it in Moralia

On your own? Play it first, then reveal.

Reveal what happened

What really happened

Rumi never confronted him and never found out. He traveled to Damascus at least twice looking for Shams and came back without him, and at some point stopped traveling and started writing: some forty thousand lines of lyric verse published under the lost man's name instead of his own, and then the Masnavi, twenty-five thousand couplets. When Ala al-Din died some years later, Rumi did not attend the funeral. He died in Konya in December 1273, and the night is still called the wedding night, the night of the meeting; his funeral is described as taking most of a day because Christians, Jews and Muslims all came. That description comes from a devotional biography written fifty years afterwards.

The philosophers weigh in

Hypatia·Ask him

"A city that agrees not to ask what happened in a courtyard is a city where it happens again. Households are not different from cities in this. They are only smaller and better at silence."

Al-Ghazali·Never ask

"There is knowledge that changes a man and knowledge that only convicts him. He spent eleven years finding out which was which, and I recognize a man who has decided he already knows the answer and cannot survive holding it."

More about Rumi →

All past stories →