The Sleigh West
December 1812 · Napoleon, retreating from his invasion of Russia with what is left of his army
He brought roughly six hundred thousand men east in the summer. What is walking west now is a column of frostbitten men who have burned their own wagons for heat and are being cut apart from behind every day.
A courier has reached him from Paris. There has been an attempted coup: a general announced he was dead, and for a few hours a good part of the government believed it and started making arrangements. It failed. It came far closer than it should have.
If he stays with the column, he shares the retreat and the men see him doing it, and Paris stays a place where his death can be announced by anyone with enough nerve.
If he goes, he can be in Paris in two weeks, hold the throne, and raise another army from a country that has not yet been told how bad this is, which is the only thing that keeps the empire standing. And the column will watch his sleigh leave.
The sleigh is ready. Almost nobody has been told.
On your own? Play it first, then reveal.
Reveal what happened
What really happened
Napoleon handed the army to Murat on 5 December 1812 and left for Paris by sleigh and carriage, traveling nearly incognito, and was back inside two weeks. He had done the same thing in Egypt in 1799. The retreat continued without him; of the men who crossed into Russia, a small fraction came out. He raised a new army of around three hundred thousand within months, which is the argument for it, and lost most of them within the year, which is the argument against. He had also, two days before leaving, issued the 29th Bulletin admitting the disaster to France and ending it with a line noting that the Emperor's health had never been better.
The philosophers weigh in
"A prince who dies nobly with his army has performed a gesture. Anyone still alive to be angry about it is alive because he went back and held the state together."
"He was never in doubt about who was expendable. The column found out in December what he had decided in June."