MORALIA
MORALIAAbout
House of the Scales19 Sep 2026

An Anointed Queen

1586 · Elizabeth I, after intercepted letters tied her cousin Mary, Queen of Scots, to a plot to kill her

The letters have been read and the plot is real. Her cousin, a crowned queen held in England for nineteen years, has been in correspondence with men who intended to kill her and put that cousin on her throne.

Parliament has asked twice. Her council asks daily. The warrant is drawn up and it sits on the desk, and everyone in the building is waiting for one signature.

Signing it means executing an anointed queen, something no one in Europe has done to a reigning monarch. It tells every Catholic power that a crown is not protection, and it invites them to test whether hers is. It also tells her own subjects that killing the queen is worth attempting, because the punishment arrived nineteen years late.

Not signing it leaves a living, legitimate alternative to her throne inside her own borders, and every plot for the rest of her life will have somewhere to point.

The pen is on the desk. It has been for three months.

Sign the warrant
"Every month she stays alive is another month someone plans around her, and mercy that costs other people their lives is not mercy."
or
Refuse to sign
"Once a monarch can be executed for what she was found writing, no monarch is safe, and you have made the argument that will one day be used on you."
Play it in Moralia

On your own? Play it first, then reveal.

Reveal what happened

What really happened

Elizabeth signed it in February 1587, and then told her secretary, William Davison, to hold it and send nothing. The council sent it anyway. Mary was beheaded at Fotheringhay on 8 February. Elizabeth wept and raged, and had Davison tried, fined ten thousand marks and imprisoned in the Tower for sending the warrant she had signed; his career never recovered. She had earlier hinted to Mary's jailer that a quiet private killing would spare her the necessity, and he had refused. She got the outcome she wanted and spent the rest of her life insisting it was not her decision.

The philosophers weigh in

Machiavelli·Sign it

"She was right to do it and wrong to spend sixteen years pretending she hadn't. The hesitation cost her more than the execution ever did."

Kant·Refuse

"If the reason is that she is dangerous rather than that she is guilty, you have not held a trial. You have removed an obstacle."

More about Elizabeth I →

All past stories →