Six of Them
Homer's Odyssey · Odysseus, sailing home with his last ship, warned by Circe of the strait ahead
The channel ahead is narrow. On one side is a whirlpool that will take the ship and everyone on it. On the other is a cliff, and in the cliff is a cave, and in the cave is something with six heads that reaches down as ships pass.
He has been told the arithmetic in advance and he believes it. Steer wide and everyone drowns. Hug the cliff and he loses six men, and only six, and the ship goes through.
So the course is decided. What is not decided is whether the crew are told.
If he tells them, men will leave the oars to look up, or freeze, or crowd to the far rail, and a ship that slows in that channel is a ship that loses more than six. If he says nothing, they row hard and straight, and six of them will be lifted off the deck without ever knowing there was a choice made about them.
They are watching him put on his armor and waiting to be told what for.
On your own? Play it first, then reveal.
Reveal what happened
What really happened
Odysseus says nothing. Homer has him admit it directly: he tells the story himself, years later, and does not defend it. He puts on his armor, takes up two spears, hugs the cliff, and Scylla takes six men off the deck while they are still rowing. He calls it the most pitiful thing he ever saw. He also does not say he would have done anything differently. Every other man who sailed with him from Troy died before Ithaca, and he came home alone.
The philosophers weigh in
"Six is not the number he chose. Six is the smallest number available, and telling them would have raised it."
"He decided which of them would die and then denied them the one thing left, which was knowing it. They rowed to their deaths as instruments."