One from Every Village
Winter 1569–70 · Elizabeth I, after the Rising of the North collapses, its earls fled, its tenants left
The rising collapsed without a battle. Two earls raised the north for the old religion and for her cousin in prison, marched south, lost their nerve, and ran for the border. The earls are gone. The tenants who followed them are still here.
The north has never really accepted her. It is Catholic, it is poor, it is three hundred miles from anyone who can enforce anything, and there is a Spanish army in the Netherlands and a living alternative queen in an English castle. If this happens again with foreign help, it is not a rising, it is an invasion with a local army waiting.
Her commander in the field wants instructions.
She can take the leaders. The men who raised it, the gentry who financed it, the ones with names: try them, attest them, and let the tenants go back to their fields, since a tenant who is called out by his landlord has not exactly volunteered.
Or she can set a number. So many from each village, chosen from among the poorest so that no one's estate is forfeited to complicate it, hanged where they lived and left up.
On your own? Play it first, then reveal.
Reveal what happened
What really happened
Quotas were set by village and carried out through the northern counties in the winter of 1569–70; estimates of those hanged run from about six hundred to eight hundred, and the instructions specified taking the poorest so that no property would fall into a lord's hands and complicate the accounting. The earls escaped over the border. There was no second northern rising. Seventeen years later she spent three months refusing to sign the warrant for the cousin the rising had been raised for, signed it, told her secretary to hold it, and then prosecuted him when the council sent it. She was also, in these same decades, funding the Dutch revolt through channels she publicly denied.
The philosophers weigh in
"The instruction to choose the poorest was not mercy toward the rich. It was bookkeeping. Once a government is choosing who dies by which deaths are administratively simplest, the question of guilt has already been closed."
"Athens debated all night whether to kill the men of Mytilene and sent a second ship to stop the first. Everyone tells that story. Nobody notices that the men who advised the killing were arguing from the correct premise about what deters a second revolt."