MORALIA
MORALIAAbout
House of the Scales15 Nov 2026

Two Shots and a Pretext

1878 · Bismarck, Chancellor of the German Empire, after two attempts on the Kaiser's life

Somebody shot at the Kaiser in May and missed. Somebody else shot at him in June and did not: he is eighty-one and badly wounded.

Neither man was a Social Democrat. The first was a tinsmith who had been expelled from the party; the second was an unemployed graduate acting alone. The police know this. It has been established within days.

What is also true is that the Social Democratic vote has been climbing every election, that the party is organized in a way no other opposition is, and that its program says the state he built is a temporary arrangement.

He can answer it as politics. The party is legal, it sits in the Reichstag, and beating it means giving working men reasons to prefer his Germany to their International, which he has ideas about and which would cost money.

Or he can dissolve the Reichstag, run an election on the shooting, and pass a law banning the party's press, its meetings, its unions and its funds, on a pretext that everyone in the building knows is a pretext.

Answer it as politics
"You know who fired and you know he was not theirs. A state that reaches for a ban the week it has an excuse has told every future government exactly what an excuse is for."
or
Ban the party
"The movement is growing and the country is frightened this month and will not be next month. You take the majority when it is in front of you, and you deal with the merits afterwards."
Play it in Moralia

On your own? Play it first, then reveal.

Reveal what happened

What really happened

He dissolved the Reichstag, ran the election on the assassination attempt, and passed the Anti-Socialist Law in October 1878. It banned the party's organizations, meetings, unions and publications for twelve years, but not its candidates, who kept standing as individuals, and whose vote went up. Then he did the other thing as well: the world's first national health insurance in 1883, accident insurance in 1884, old-age and disability pensions in 1889, and he said in the Reichstag exactly why, which was to give the working man something to lose. The law lapsed in 1890, the year he was forced out. At the next election the party he had banned became the largest in Germany by vote share.

The philosophers weigh in

Wollstonecraft·Answer it

"He is about to prove, at public expense and over twelve years, that you cannot legislate a conviction out of people who hold it because of their circumstances. The circumstances were the argument all along and he knew it, since he then paid to change them."

Machiavelli·Ban it

"He banned them and bought them in the same decade, and only one of those is remembered as cynical. Both were the same instrument. He simply had the stomach to use the whole of it."

More about Otto von Bismarck →

All past stories →