MORALIA
MORALIAAbout
House of the Oath2 Oct 2026

Twice Against Philosophy

323 BC · Aristotle, Alexander's old tutor, charged with impiety as Athens turns on all things Macedonian

The news from Babylon has reached the city and Athens has decided it is free again. Anything Macedonian is now a target, and he has been the most visible Macedonian in Athens for twelve years; he tutored the boy, and everyone knows it.

The charge brought against him is impiety. It is the same charge, in the same courts, that killed Socrates seventy-six years ago in this city, and everyone involved knows that too.

He is sixty-one. He has a school with a library, a collection of specimens, and students in the middle of work that will have to go on without him. If he stays and stands trial, he can argue (he has spent his life on argument) and he will probably lose, because the trial is not about impiety.

If he goes, the school has to carry on without him, the charge stands unanswered, and every man in Athens gets to say the philosopher ran.

There is a house at Chalcis, across the strait, that belonged to his mother's family. The boat leaves in the morning.

Take the boat
"Dying to make a point is the one contribution anyone can make. Living is the only way the forty years of work behind you reaches anybody."
or
Stay and stand trial
"A philosopher who will not answer a charge in the city that raised him has already conceded the argument, whatever the verdict says."
Play it in Moralia

On your own? Play it first, then reveal.

Reveal what happened

What really happened

Aristotle left. Later writers record him saying he would not let Athens sin twice against philosophy. He died at Chalcis the following year, aged sixty-two, of natural causes, and left a will that freed several of his slaves and provided for his household. The Lyceum survived him under Theophrastus. The library eventually reached Rome. For centuries afterwards he was known in the Latin and Arabic worlds simply as 'the Philosopher', a status Socrates (who stayed) has never quite had, and a body of work Socrates (who wrote nothing) never produced.

The philosophers weigh in

Diogenes·Leave

"Of course he left. A man who has spent twelve years explaining moderation to Athenians is not going to start being immoderate about his own funeral."

Marcus Aurelius·Stand trial

"He spent his life teaching that courage sits between recklessness and cowardice, and then had to locate the middle with his own name on the indictment. That is the only test that counts."

More about Aristotle →

All past stories →